In our twenty-first installment, we continue exploring the evolving landscape of Mets prospects as documented by *Baseball Digest*. In 1983, the publication highlighted ten Mets players, signaling a significant upswing in the team's farm system and indicating that good things were on the horizon for the New York Mets. Among those featured were Darryl Strawberry, Scott Holman, Brian Giles, Walt Terrell, Doug Sisk, Ron Darling, José Oquendo, Jeff Bittiger, and Tim Leary. Let's delve into the careers of these players, particularly those who played key roles in the 1986 World Series, and examine whether they lived up to the expectations set forth by *Baseball Digest* in March 1983.
Darryl Strawberry: Living Up to the Hype
Scouting Report:"Outstanding potential, MVP Texas League Can do it all. Chance to be a star player."
In 1983, Darryl Strawberry was touted as a player with "outstanding potential" in his scouting report published in *Baseball Digest*. The report highlighted his MVP performance in the Texas League, emphasizing that he had the chance to become a star, with the ability to do it all on the baseball field. Fast forward to his career, and the predictions about his potential were largely accurate, though his journey was far from straightforward.
Strawberry's career began with the New York Mets in 1983, and he quickly became a key figure in their lineup. Over his eight seasons with the Mets, he developed into one of the most feared sluggers in baseball. His Mets tenure was marked by significant achievements, including eight consecutive All-Star selections from 1984 to 1991, a National League Rookie of the Year award in 1983, and a crucial role in leading the Mets to a World Series championship in 1986.
Statistically, Strawberry's impact with the Mets was undeniable. He hit 252 home runs during his time in New York, leading the National League in homers with 39 in 1988. His combination of power, speed, and defensive prowess earned him a reputation as one of the most dynamic players in the game. However, the scouting report's optimistic view of his potential didn't fully account for the challenges he would face off the field, which would ultimately shape his career.
Despite his on-field success, Strawberry's career was marred by personal struggles, particularly with substance abuse. These issues, which began to surface during his time with the Mets, would follow him throughout his career and beyond, impacting his consistency and longevity in the game. After leaving the Mets in 1990, Strawberry signed with the Los Angeles Dodgers, but injuries and continued struggles limited his effectiveness. He played for the Dodgers and the San Francisco Giants before reuniting with his former Mets manager, Joe Torre, on the New York Yankees. Strawberry found some redemption with the Yankees, winning three more World Series titles (1996, 1998, and 1999), though his role was more limited than during his prime years with the Mets.
In total, Strawberry finished his career with 335 home runs, 1,000 RBIs, and a .259 batting average. While these numbers reflect a successful career, they also hint at what might have been if not for the off-field issues that hampered his performance and availability. His time with the Mets remains the highlight of his career, showcasing the potential that scouts saw in him as a young player. Despite the hurdles he faced, Strawberry's legacy in baseball is cemented as a player who, at his best, was among the most electrifying in the game. However, his story also serves as a reminder of how personal challenges can intersect with and impact professional success.
Doug Sisk: The Sleeper Who Never Fully Awoke
Scouting Report: "Sinker/Slider type pitcher with good command. Came up from Double A to Majors in late season. Relief pitcher; a sleeper."
The 1983 scouting report on Doug Sisk in Baseball Digest described him as a "sinker/slider type pitcher with good command" and labeled him a "sleeper" after his late-season call-up from Double-A to the majors. This assessment aligned with the early part of Sisk's career, where his sinker was his most effective pitch, known for inducing ground balls and making it difficult for batters to hit balls in the air. This pitch allowed Sisk to make an immediate impact in the major leagues, particularly in his early years with the New York Mets.
Sisk debuted in September 1982, and his performance quickly validated the scouting report's optimism. In his first full season in 1983, Sisk was a valuable asset in the Mets' bullpen, complementing left-hander Jesse Orosco. He recorded a solid 2.24 ERA over 103.2 innings and saved 11 games. These numbers suggest that the scouting report was accurate in predicting Sisk's ability to be a reliable relief pitcher at the major league level.
However, the "sleeper" label also implied that Sisk had the potential to develop into something more, possibly even a star. While Sisk's early success supported this notion, his career took a different trajectory due to injuries and declining effectiveness. In 1984, Sisk was off to a brilliant start with an ERA of just 0.47 through his first 53.2 innings, suggesting that he could be an elite reliever. However, a sore shoulder derailed his season, and although he finished with a respectable 2.09 ERA, the seeds of his later struggles were planted.
By 1985, injuries began to take their toll on Sisk's performance. His ERA ballooned to 8.53 before being demoted to Triple-A. Although he managed to return to the majors and post better numbers later in the season, he was never quite the same pitcher. Over the next few years, Sisk became a target for fans' frustrations, particularly in Shea Stadium, despite some solid statistical performances. For instance, in 1986, he managed a 2.62 ERA despite being used primarily in low-leverage situations.
Sisk's career was marked by inconsistency and a series of injuries that prevented him from fully realizing the potential hinted at in his scouting report. Although he finished his nine-year MLB career with a respectable 3.27 ERA over 523.1 innings, his inability to sustain his early success ultimately defined his career. The scouting report’s suggestion that he was a "sleeper" was accurate to some extent, but the injuries and his struggles in high-pressure situations prevented Sisk from becoming a more dominant force in the majors.
In summary, Doug Sisk's career followed the early predictions to some degree—his sinker was indeed a formidable pitch, and he played an essential role in the Mets' bullpen. However, injuries and inconsistency meant that he never fully lived up to the potential that the scouting report hinted at. The "sleeper" never quite woke up to become a star, but Sisk's contributions were still significant, especially in the early years of his career.
Spot-On Projection: The Accurate Scouting of Ron Darling’s Rise to Stardom
Scouting Report: "Also part of Lee Mazzilli trade. All-American from Yale. Has the arm and the make-up to become front line starter. May need one more season in AAA."
Ron Darling's 1983 scouting report in *Baseball Digest* described him as having "the arm and the make-up to become a front-line starter" and suggested he might need one more season in AAA before making his MLB impact. This assessment was remarkably accurate. Darling, then a promising pitcher out of Yale, spent most of 1983 in AAA, honing his control and refining his game, just as the scouts predicted.
By 1984, Darling had fulfilled the expectations laid out in his scouting report, securing a spot in the Mets' starting rotation and ending the season with a solid 12-9 record and a 3.81 ERA. The following year, Darling had a breakout season, posting a 16-6 record, earning an All-Star selection, and establishing himself as a cornerstone of the Mets' pitching staff. His performance in the 1986 season and the World Series, where he delivered key outings in Games 1 and 4, further validated the scouts' early projections, helping the Mets to clinch the championship.
Throughout his career, Darling consistently demonstrated the potential the scouts had seen in him, becoming one of the Mets' most reliable starters during the mid-to-late 1980s. Although control issues lingered early on, as the scouting report suggested might be a concern, he gradually overcame them, finishing his career with 136 wins, including 99 with the Mets, and earning a Gold Glove in 1989. His versatility, with a repertoire of five different pitches, also underscored the accuracy of the scouting report's assessment of his potential.
After retiring, Darling seamlessly transitioned to a successful career as a broadcaster, bringing the same intelligence and competitive spirit to his analysis of the game. His induction into the Mets Hall of Fame in 2020 cemented his legacy, fulfilling and even surpassing the expectations set by his early scouting report. Darling’s journey from a promising young pitcher to a celebrated MLB player and commentator highlights just how spot-on that initial assessment was, proving that the scouts had seen in him exactly what he would become—a star.
As we explore the careers of the players highlighted by *Baseball Digest* in 1983, it's clear that many of these prospects lived up to their potential and then some. Darryl Strawberry, Doug Sisk, and Ron Darling, among others, became integral to the Mets' 1986 World Series championship team, a historic triumph that marked the first World Series win for the franchise since 1969. Strawberry's explosive bat and charismatic presence, Sisk’s reliable bullpen performances, and Darling’s ace-caliber pitching all played pivotal roles in this championship run. Their success was not merely a product of their individual talents but also a testament to the foresight of those early scouting reports. The journey of these players underscores the importance of scouting accuracy and the impact it can have on shaping a team's future. In our next installment, we will continue to track the evolution of Mets prospects and the continuing influence of *Baseball Digest*'s predictions.
Comments