top of page

In Memoriam: Stan Cliburn — The Lifer

3 minutes ago
7 min read



Here is the whole of Stan Cliburn's major league career, and you can read it faster than he lived it: 54 games, 56 at-bats, 10 hits, two home runs, a .179 batting average, one summer — 1980 — with the California Angels. Most men, handed a line like that, would have taken the hint. Stan Cliburn took it as a starting point. He played seven more seasons in the minors, most of them in towns the big leagues fly over, and then he managed for 38 years, piling up more than 2,100 victories — 12th on the all-time minor league list — in places like Watertown and Alexandria and Waldorf, Maryland. He was still at it this summer, managing the Chicago Dogs at 69 years old, with his identical twin brother as his pitching coach, because of course he was. Stan Cliburn died on Thursday, a month before his 70th birthday, having spent 52 of his 69 years in a uniform.



He never played for the Mets, never managed against them in the big leagues, never so much as wore the laundry. But if you love this game — the whole game, not just the televised part — Stan Cliburn was one of yours. He was the patron saint of the bus leagues, and the bus leagues are where baseball actually lives.


He was born in Jackson, Mississippi, on December 19, 1956, and he did not arrive alone. Stanley Gene Cliburn beat his brother Stewart into the world by 20 minutes, and the two of them spent the next seven decades as a matched set — dressed alike, seated together in class, inseparable. Stan became a catcher at the age of 7 because the Boys Club coach needed one, and he became the catcher because of a Little League coin flip that history should record properly: the twins took turns pitching and catching for each other, Stan lost a game, and Stew delivered the verdict — "I must be a better pitcher than you." Done. One twin on the mound, the other behind the plate, for the rest of their lives.



They starred together at Forest Hill High School — Stan the football quarterback, Stew his receiver — and led the school to its first state baseball championship at 29–1, Stan hitting .450. He learned he had been drafted in the fifth round by the Angels from a newspaper he opened between golf shots on his senior class trip. The bonus was $12,000, plus a $5,000 incentive if he ever spent 90 days in the major leagues. File that number away. It becomes important, and hilarious.


The climb took six years, and it was the full tour: a 17-year-old crying on his parents' shoulders after a demotion in Davenport; sharing the catching at Quad Cities with a kid named Joe Maddon, who even then was, in Stan's words, "the Wizard of Oz on our team"; catching Nolan Ryan and Frank Tanana in spring-training bullpens and trying to look stern about it; a night in El Paso where he hit two home runs and the fans passed a batting helmet and stuffed it with $330 in bills — "more than I made in a two-week paycheck." At Salinas in 1977 he hit .311 and made the California League All-Star team. At Portland in 1979 he came to bat against Stew, by then pitching in the Pirates' system, for the first time in their lives. "He knows I'm a fastball hitter," Stan said. Stew threw one. Stan popped it up to the first baseman on the first pitch. Somewhere in that one pitch is the entire history of brothers.


The Show, when it finally came, came by ambulance: seven games into the 1980 season, Angels All-Star catcher Brian Downing broke his ankle, and Stan Cliburn, 23 years old and six years a minor leaguer, flew to join the big club. He was a backup behind Tom Donohue, a late-inning defensive replacement, and then, on May 22 in Texas, he got a start — in front of more than 160 family members and friends who had driven 400 miles from Jackson to watch. He singled off Jon Matlack for his first major league hit and scored on a Rod Carew single. Manager Jim Fregosi told him, "I liked what I saw tonight. You're going to be my catcher here for a while." He didn't start again for a month. "It crushed me," he said, and if you have ever been 23 and brilliant for one night and benched for a month, you know that sentence is the whole autobiography of the fringe big leaguer.


But what a summer he stuffed into the margins. He hit his first home run on July 25, off Cleveland's Ross Grimsley, and a week later, in Toronto, a stranger slid into his cab and congratulated him — the stranger was Bobby Doerr. At the All-Star break, American League President Lee McPhail invited the rookie backup to serve as the AL's bullpen catcher for the All-Star Game at Dodger Stadium, and Stan Cliburn spent three days warming up All-Stars alongside his boyhood idol, Johnny Bench. And then there is the 90th day. Remember the $5,000 bonus for 90 days of service? On day 89, Stan announced to the clubhouse, "My 90th day is tomorrow. Drinks on me tomorrow night." That day Fregosi called him in and told him he was being sent back to Double-A — at which point Joe Rudi, Don Baylor, Tom Donohue and Brian Downing burst out of the manager's bathroom, laughing themselves sick. He stayed. He earned the bonus. His second and final big-league home run came on August 17, a solo shot off a fellow named Jerry Koosman. "I never got the chance to play on a consistent basis," he said years later. "I never understood why. It wasn't like the other guys were knocking the place dead."


The Angels released him the next spring — "the toughest day of my life" — and baseball, which has a sense of humor if you wait long enough, sent him to Double-A Buffalo, where the pitching staff included Stew. They had not been teammates in seven years. "It was like going back to high school," Stan said. In their second game as a battery, Stew threw a two-hit complete game and won 6–2, throwing to his twin. They never did it in the majors — Stan's one summer ended four years before Stew's 1984 debut, when the Cliburns became the seventh set of twins in big-league history and the only pair ever to play for the Angels — but they did it everywhere else that mattered, including one more summer together at Triple-A Edmonton in 1986. Stew, by the way, was no footnote: 13–5 with a 3.11 ERA across three Angels seasons, 9–3 with a 2.09 ERA in 1985, fifth in the Rookie of the Year voting. The pitcher was the famous one. The catcher became the institution.


He started managing in 1988 because Pittsburgh offered him $35,000 to coach — double his salary as a player — and he understood the job instantly and forever: "It's not about you anymore. It's about 25 players with different styles of play and different egos, and you have to adjust to each of those 25 players." In his second season he won the South Atlantic League championship with Augusta. At Salem, a farm director told him, "I think you need to learn how to lose," and Stan, who did not like the lesson, admitted it made him a better manager. At independent Alexandria, where there were no other coaches and he recruited his own roster, he won two championships in three years. Then the Minnesota Twins hired him, and the lifer became a finishing school: at Double-A New Britain, with Stew as his pitching coach, he won the 2001 Eastern League co-championship and Manager of the Year, and shepherded Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau, Michael Cuddyer and Francisco Liriano toward Minneapolis. The Rock Cats once sold a two-sided Cliburn bobblehead — Stan on one side, Stew on the other — which remains the most honest piece of merchandise in minor league history. At Triple-A Rochester he won 300 games and took the Red Wings to the 2006 Governors' Cup Finals. His credo never changed, from a 1993 interview to the end: "I want everybody to have a chance. I want everybody to do well. I'm in everybody's corner, and I care for them and their careers."



There were hard years — 2009, when the Twins split the twins up for the first time in eight years, when their mother died that August, when Rochester let him go and Stew said the thing that should be carved over a clubhouse door somewhere: "Baseball — it's a great game, but sometimes it steps on your heart." Stan fought through a dark stretch after his parents died and came out the other side saying the getting-help part "was the best thing I've ever done." By 2014 he was rejuvenated — "I couldn't wait to get to the park" — and the last decade was a victory lap nobody told him to take: Southern Maryland, a return to New Britain, a bench-coach seat with the expansion Chicago Dogs in 2018, back to Southern Maryland for seven more seasons. He won his 2,000th game in July 2024. He stepped down last December with 2,083 wins, 12th all-time — and then, because retirement is a rumor Stan Cliburn never believed, he signed on for one more summer, managing the 2026 Chicago Dogs with Stew at his side, and won 31 more.


The tributes came from every stop on the map. The Dogs called him "the heart of our clubhouse" and wrote that he was "one of the most successful managers in minor league baseball history, but he was an even greater human being." Rochester president Naomi Silver said, "He embodied what it means to be a Minor League manager," and remembered picturing him "in our dugout alongside his twin brother, Stu — you could see how much they enjoyed being together." His old outfielder Dario Pizzano may have said it simplest: "He had his players' back — always."


He leaves his wife, Tanya, whom he married in 1979; his son, Patrick; his sister, Regina; his brother Roger; and Stew — the other half of the battery, who now has to go on without his catcher. "It's like being a brother," Stew once said, "but magnified." Baseball is full of men who got a summer. Stan Cliburn got one summer, and then he gave the game 46 more years anyway — every level, every bus, every 40th-round pick who needed one person in his corner. For nearly half a century, in a hundred clubhouses, that person was Stan.


Rest easy, Skip. You were in everybody's corner. Now we're in yours.



🔔 Get the Korner in Your Inbox


The Rumor Roundup, the Chronicles, Sunday School and everything from the Korner — delivered free every Sunday morning, plus a breaking-edition alert when the Mets make a move. Just drop your email in the form below and you're in.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page