Rheingold Retro Radio Days No. 5: The Clincher

St. Louis Cardinals at New York Mets · Shea Stadium · Wednesday, September 24, 1969
The Magic Number Was One
The Cubs had done their part that afternoon in Chicago, beating Montreal 6–3 to keep alive their chance of a tie, and so the whole pennant race had been reduced to one game, on the last night of the home schedule, in front of a Shea Stadium crowd that had been arriving since batting practice. The booth laid it out plainly during the bottom of the first, and it is worth hearing exactly how simple it had become:
"The pennant race in the Eastern Division of the National League has come down simply to this. If the New York Mets can win this ballgame here tonight, they win the championship in the Eastern Division. The magic number is one."
Ralph Kiner read the lineups before the game. Then the play-by-play chair was handed to a fellow introduced as having "done just about everything big that you can do on radio and television, and done it with the best of them" — Lindsey Nelson — and Nelson opened with the truest sentence of the season: this was, "for the Mets and Mets fans, the biggest baseball game ever played in the stadium." The booth called it a carnival atmosphere, with an air of electricity around the stands. On the mound: a 22-year-old rookie from Phoenix named Gary Gentry, 11–12 on the year, against Steve Carlton, who had won 17.
Five Runs in the First
Gentry set the tone in the top half — Lou Brock struck out, Curt Flood lined to right, Vada Pinson flied to right — and then the Mets came to bat and ended the suspense in about fifteen minutes. Bud Harrelson singled to right. Tommie Agee walked, the booth doing the pennant math over the top of the at-bat. Cleon Jones, back in the starting lineup for the first time since September 11 and carrying a .346 average and the league batting lead, got the ovation of the night — somewhere down below, a fan was holding up a sign that said TONIGHT'S THE NIGHT — and then struck out. It was the only out Steve Carlton would get.
Donn Clendenon drove the next one over the center field fence, Harrelson and Agee ahead of him: "The Mets are out in front by a score of three to nothing." Ron Swoboda walked. And then Ed Charles — 35 years old, hitting .199, with two home runs all season — turned on one and sent it toward the right field wall, Pinson back, up… and gone:
"His third home run of the year — over the right field fence, the right-center field fence. A two-run homer that scored Swoboda ahead of him. The New York Mets are leading five-nothing, and that is all for Steve Carlton."

Carlton's night: six batters, one out, five runs. Dave Giusti came in and Jerry Grote doubled off him for good measure, and during the Charles at-bat the booth had paused to read a letter from an Army chaplain in Korea — the servicemen over there, he wrote, were following the fortunes of the New York Mets day by day. On this night, so was everybody.

Gentry Finished What He Started
After the first, the game went quiet and stayed quiet, which was its own kind of tension. Giusti settled the Cardinals down; the only other run came in the fifth, when Clendenon hit his second homer of the night, a solo shot to right, for 6–0 and four runs batted in. Gentry, meanwhile, was carving: a single by Brock in the fourth erased on a double play, a Shannon single in the fifth, nothing else. Two double plays behind him, four hits total, and a crowd that spent the late innings exactly the way the booth described it in the ninth — not a soul leaving, the aisles jammed, everybody standing by the exits with their fingers crossed on what the play-by-play man called, weather-wise, "a perfect night for the big one."

The ninth nearly spoiled the script. Brock singled up the middle, Davalillo singled to center, and with the tying run nowhere near the plate but 54,928 people suddenly remembering every collapse in franchise history, Ed Charles came across from third base to have a word with his young pitcher. Pinson struck out. Joe Torre, the last man standing between the Mets and the pennant, grounded to Harrelson — to Weis — to Clendenon. Double play. Ballgame. Championship.
The fans came over the walls and onto the field, banners paraded around the warning track, and in the booth they were remembering the manager: Gil Hodges, who a year ago to the very day had suffered a heart attack in Atlanta, had taken his ballclub to a championship. The Mets were champions of the National League East — 96 and 61, six games clear of the Cubs, and the Miracle had a flag to show for itself.
About This Broadcast
The recording is a Mets Baseball Network aircheck — it survives off WKAJ-FM 102.3 in Saratoga Springs, station identifications and all — and reaches us through the Internet Archive. The sponsor material stays in, as always: the full Rheingold spot rolls in the first-inning break, ten-minute head and all — "My beer is Rheingold, the dry beer" — and after the game there is a Rheingold Chug-a-Mug spot for dessert. Stick around after the final out, too, for Ralph Kiner's clubhouse show from what he called "the happiest clubhouse in America," where one Met, champagne pending, put the whole night in one sentence: "I'm glad we won it here in New York. I think they deserve it more than we do, almost."
📻 LISTEN: The Complete Broadcast

Box score: Retrosheet via Baseball-Reference.
Next on Rheingold Retro Radio Days: another classic from the archive. See you Tuesday.
🔔 Get the Korner in Your Inbox
The Rumor Roundup, the Chronicles, Sunday School and everything from the Korner — delivered free every Sunday morning, plus a breaking-edition alert when the Mets make a move. Just drop your email in the form below and you're in.





Comments