top of page

Scroogie and Michael Witte's Amazing Baseball Journey Part Three




In the realm of baseball, the Witte legacy stands as a testament to the unpredictable nature of the game, filled with triumphs, setbacks, and unexpected turns.


Spencer Witte, once a high school All-American second baseman in Nyack, New York, embarked on a journey that would redefine his relationship with baseball. Michael Witte, his father, paints a vivid picture of Spencer's early days in the sport.Spencer's prowess on the field was undeniable, earning him recognition as a second team second baseman for the Baseball Factory. However, the promising trajectory took an unforeseen turn as he grappled with throwing anxiety, a challenge reminiscent of Chuck Knoblauch's struggles. Despite his exceptional skills, Spencer faced rejection from 12 out of 13 colleges he applied to, leading him on a winding path to North Carolina.




Undeterred, Spencer's resilience came to the fore as he redirected his focus from the field to academics. Excelling at the University of North Carolina Asheville, he later transferred to Temple in Philadelphia. His dedication to overcoming throwing anxiety and academic success continued at the University of Pennsylvania, where he earned straight A's and showcased his hitting prowess as a designated hitter for the Penn baseball team.



The narrative takes an unexpected twist as Spencer, driven by a desire to make a difference in the Middle East, immersed himself in Arabic studies in Syria. His academic journey led him to Oxford, where he earned a master's degree in international relations and Arabic, defying the odds of past rejections.


The turning point in the Witte story came with their foray into baseball consulting. Leaving behind the St. Louis Cardinals and facing initial rejections, the Witte duo founded Classic Baseball LLC. Over a remarkable decade, they consulted with an astonishing 20 out of the 30 major league teams, showcasing Spencer's analytical brilliance and deep understanding of the evolving technological landscape in baseball.


As Michael reflects on their journey, a note of Schadenfreude enters the narrative. The rejection from the Yankees, who dismissed their one-hour free presentation, contrasts sharply with the success Classic Baseball LLC achieved. Michael takes pleasure in watching the Yankees' lavish spending on choices that failed to yield the desired outcomes, providing a touch of irony and vindication.


While acknowledging that not every venture was a resounding success, the Witte duo's impact on the baseball landscape is undeniable. As they navigated the intricacies of the game, Spencer's former player perspective and analytical acumen contributed to their many successes. The journey, marked by both triumphs and failures, underscores the unpredictability of the sport.


Now, at the age of 80, Michael Witte revels in the joy of witnessing the legacy they've built. The Witte story is more than a tale of baseball success; it's a testament to the enduring spirit of those who dare to dream and overcome obstacles. As we celebrate their resilience, triumphs, and the joy they continue to find in the game, the Witte legacy remains an inspiring chapter in the annals of baseball history considering it all started because of a cartoon strip.

96 views0 comments
bottom of page