top of page

Kiners Korner Chronicles No. 16: The Night Cone Arrived

4 hours ago
6 min read


Welcome back to the Kiners Korner Chronicles — the real ones. We've brought back Tom Seaver's homecoming, a new owner taking his seat, an umpire holding court in a rain delay, Gary Carter's first day as a Met, and Lenny Dykstra alongside his best fan. This time we rewind to Thursday, May 7, 1987, and a game you will not find in any record book: a charity exhibition at Shea between the two clubs that had played the World Series seven months earlier, started by a 24-year-old right-hander who needed a good night more than anybody else in the ballpark.


David Cone had been a Met for six weeks. He came over from Kansas City on March 27 in the Ed Hearn deal — a trade that would come to be called the worst in Royals history — and he arrived at the worst possible moment: Dwight Gooden was in rehab, Bob Ojeda was hurt, and Davey Johnson's four-man rotation gamble pulled the kid out of the bullpen and into the rotation. His first two starts were a beating. So Davey handed him the softest assignment on the calendar, an exhibition that didn't count, and told him to go find himself. What happened that night is where the David Cone story really starts.


The Game — Thursday, May 7, 1987


A crowd of 32,247 came to Shea for the second annual charity game between the Mets and the Boston Red Sox — proceeds split between the Jimmy Fund and the Mets' amateur baseball program — and Cone gave them seven scoreless innings: three hits, two walks, eight strikeouts, the longest and best outing of his young career. He struck out the side in the seventh. Randy Myers closed it with two scoreless innings of his own.


The Mets needed only two runs, and Rafael Santana drove in both of them, and Lee Mazzilli scored both of them. In the second, Mazzilli singled, took second on a wild pitch, stole third, and came home on Santana's groundout. In the fourth, Mookie Wilson singled, Mazzilli reached on a force play, Howard Johnson walked, and Santana singled through the hole for a 2–0 lead. Dave Magadan made the defensive play of the night, a leaping grab on Mike Greenwell at first base to protect the lead, and Lenny Dykstra hauled in Ed Romero's drive for the final out. The hard-luck loser was Tom Bolton, a left-hander on loan from Pawtucket, who allowed both runs in six strong innings — a showing good enough that Boston purchased his contract two days later.


One honest footnote: because this was an exhibition, no official box score of it exists anywhere. The one at the bottom of this post was reconstructed, plate appearance by plate appearance, from the WWOR broadcast of the game — and it checks against the broadcast's own score bugs and running totals at every checkpoint.


The Show




Ralph wastes no time on the important stuff — the Coneheads. The fans in the cone hats had already found the new kid. “Even though he's new to the New York area,” Ralph tells the audience, “the fans have picked up on him right off the top, as they have come up with a new gimmick out here — the David Cone hats.” Then he gets to the pitching: “The walks were down, the strikeouts were up. Everything looked great.” Cone, in a gray NEW YORK Mets t-shirt, changed out of his uniform but still wearing his game pants, knows exactly why he was out there: “I knew I needed the work. Obviously I'd been struggling lately. And Mel Stottlemyre and myself have been working hard in the bullpen — just basically trying to throw strikes and get ahead of the hitters.”


Ralph asks the question the whole night turns on: two tough starts — did you lose any confidence? Did it bother you? Cone doesn't flinch. “I'd be lying if I said I didn't. You know, you try not to let that stuff affect you. I know I can pitch on this level — it's just a matter of getting the opportunities to do so. I've had some prime opportunities and I haven't taken advantage of them, and I realize that they're few and far between. So I really need to bear down and show what I can do on this level if I expect to stay.”


Then Ralph turns to the arsenal — the big curveball, and that little slider Cone drops down with. Any special reason for the sidearm pitch? “It's a pitch that I worked on in Puerto Rico. I learned it from Gaylord Perry. And the way to make it effective is not to use it too much — to save it for a tough situation against a tough right-handed hitter like Jack Clark. You won't see me use it against left-handers.” Ralph nods at the St. Louis evidence: “You handled his case well over in St. Louis.” Cone: “That's the type of hitter that it's effective against. You have to save it for the right time, and the element of surprise is what makes it effective.”


And then Ralph, who had been waiting for this, goes straight at the legend: “Did you ever learn anything else from Gaylord Perry — like a spitball?” Cone grins: “Well, that's kind of incriminating.” Ralph, merciful: “You don't have to answer that. You can take the Fifth.” Cone: “He told me — when I get to where I can't throw the ball hard anymore, he'll teach me that pitch.”


Ralph rolls the strikeout reel — six of the eight — and when a Conehead pops up on the screen, he can't resist: “How about that? You've got your own fan club, David.” Then Cone talks through his own night like a pitching coach. Wade Boggs, on a fastball: “I'd thrown him a couple of breaking balls early in the count, and I just reared back and threw it by him.” Marty Barrett, fooled by a slider: “I got him 0-and-2, and I wanted to make sure I got it out and away from him. Luckily, I got him to go for it.” Ed Romero, on a 3-and-2 slider: “It looked like it was going to be inside, and just kind of dipped over the inside corner.” Ellis Burks, on the curve: “It started out, it looked like it was going to be a strike, and it broke down and away.” Glenn Hoffman gets the specialty of the house — “There's the sidearm slider I learned” — and Marc Sullivan a running fastball up and in: “I really wanted to rear back and make sure I got it inside.” Ralph delivers the verdict: “Well, that's major-league stuff right there, David. And certainly this should get you back on the track.”


Cone finishes the way he finished the game. “I'm really looking forward to building on this, as far as my next start goes. I think there's a lot of positive things tonight, and I'm hoping that I can carry that into my next start.” Ralph notes it was the longest Cone had pitched since coming to the major leagues; Cone agrees, and says it felt good to stretch it out, prove he could finish strong, and that he was happy with the way he finished. The highlights follow, and Ralph signs off on the evening by noting the clubs had signed up for two more of these — one in Boston next year, one back at Shea. Stick around to the very end of the tape, by the way, and you'll catch a pre-Seinfeld Jason Alexander turning up in the Miller Lite commercial.


The epilogue writes itself, and it isn't all kind. Three weeks later, an Atlee Hammaker pitch crushed Cone's right pinky while he was bunting, and it cost him nearly three months. But the pitcher who showed up the following spring was the finished article: 20–3 with a 2.22 ERA in 1988, second in the Cy Young voting, and on his way to becoming one of the defining pitchers of his generation — most of it, as the Coneheads could have told you, still ahead of him in a Mets uniform. It started on a night that didn't count, in a game the record books forgot. The tape remembers.


More rescued shows are on the way as we work through the tapes one by one. And if you're sitting on a tape of this show — any tape, any year — the hunt is still on, and we want to hear from you.


Down on the Korner — the book Howie and I wrote about this show and these Mets — is available here.


Watch the rescued episodes as we revisit them: the Kiner's Korner archive playlist.


Box score: Retrosheet via Baseball-Reference.


🔔 Get the Korner in Your Inbox


The Rumor Roundup, the Chronicles, Sunday School and everything from the Korner — delivered free every Sunday morning, plus a breaking-edition alert when the Mets make a move. Just drop your email in the form below and you're in.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page