top of page

Sunday School: Forgotten Faces of Flushing #98: The Immortal in the Dugout

2 minutes ago
7 min read

Last week on Sunday School, Forgotten Faces of Flushing, we met Mark Carreon — the catcher's son who reached Shea Stadium six days after his father died. The family run pauses this week. This week's face is not obscure, not a third brother. He is, by any honest accounting, the greatest right-handed hitter who ever lived.


And for one summer, he worked for the worst team in baseball history.


In the spring of 1962, the New York Mets' batting instructor wore uniform No. 53 at the Polo Grounds. His name was Rogers Hornsby. He had been a member of the Baseball Hall of Fame for twenty years — elected in 1942, before most of his pupils were born. Casey Stengel, managing the club, would not reach Cooperstown until 1966. George Weiss, who built it, waited until 1971. Richie Ashburn and Gil Hodges, who played on it, waited decades more. In 1962, there was exactly one man in that dugout whose plaque was already on the wall, and he was the hitting coach.


This series has spent ninety-seven weeks remembering the men Mets fans forgot. This week we remember the one they never knew they had.


The Rajah


Rogers Hornsby was born on April 27, 1896, in Winters, Texas, and grew up around Fort Worth. What he became can be said in one number: .358 — a lifetime batting average across twenty-three major-league seasons, second only to Ty Cobb's, and the highest any right-handed hitter has ever carried. Nobody has come particularly close since.


The prime was not a peak. It was a plateau. From 1920 through 1925, six full seasons, Hornsby averaged .402. He hit .401 in 1922 — with 42 home runs, making him still the only man ever to bat .400 and hit 40 homers in the same season. He hit .424 in 1924, the highest average of the modern era, a record that has now stood for a century. He hit .403 in 1925. Three .400 seasons. Two Triple Crowns — a feat only he and Ted Williams have ever managed. Seven batting titles, six of them in a row. Two Most Valuable Player Awards, nine years apart, for two different franchises. And in 1926, as player-manager, he led the St. Louis Cardinals to their first World Series championship.


He was a monk about the one gift. Hornsby would not go to the movies during the season, and he would not read — not newspapers, not books — for fear of straining the eyes that were his fortune. He did not drink and he did not smoke. The one vice was the racetrack, and it cost him jobs and goodwill all his life. He also had the most famous winter in baseball. "People ask me what I do in winter when there's no baseball," he said. "I'll tell you what I do. I stare out the window and wait for spring."



Twenty Years a Hall of Famer


The writers elected Hornsby to the Hall of Fame in January 1942, on his fifth ballot, with 78 percent of the vote. Because of the war, there was no induction ceremony that summer — the plaque went up without the party. He had managed in the big leagues by then, too, and he kept managing: six clubs across fourteen seasons, the last of them the Cincinnati Reds of 1952 and '53. He won his one pennant in 1926 and never stopped telling players exactly what he thought of them, which is why the managing jobs kept ending.


Understand what Hornsby was by 1961: sixty-five years old, nine years out of a major-league uniform, the most brilliant and least diplomatic man in the game. He had spent a lifetime being right about hitting and impossible about everything else. The Mets were about to be born, and they needed somebody to grade the National League's players ahead of the expansion draft.


They hired the Rajah as a scout.



Casey Comes Calling


George Weiss, the Mets' first president, brought Hornsby aboard late in 1961 to scout the other National League clubs out of Chicago. Then Casey Stengel asked him to come south and coach. In January 1962, at the press conference where Stengel held up a sketch of the new club's uniform, Rogers Hornsby was signed as the Mets' batting coach. The franchise's own program that spring listed him plainly: 53 — HORNSBY, Rogers (Rajah).


There was, strictly speaking, no such job as "hitting coach" in 1962 — the title would not become standard for another decade. Hornsby was a batting instructor, the first the Mets ever had, on a coaching staff that belonged in a museum: Stengel was seventy-one, Hornsby sixty-five, and the pitching coach was Red Ruffing, who had won 273 games for the Yankees. The expansion Mets could not play. Nobody could say they lacked for teachers.


His doctrine fit in one sentence: hit the ball back up the middle. Stengel, who preferred his hitters to shoot the ball down the lines — that, Casey reasoned, was where the worst fielders played — enjoyed pointing out that Hornsby could preach the middle because Hornsby could hit it over the center-field fence. The pupils could not. The pupils hit .240 as a team, the lowest mark in the majors.


He did not coddle them. The warmest compliment a Hornsby scouting report ever contained was "the guy looks like a major leaguer." Ed Kranepool, an eighteen-year-old rookie that September, remembered that the only instruction the great man ever gave him was this: "They don't make them like they used to. Swing at a strike." The Sporting News photographed him tutoring Gil Hodges — one future Hall of Famer taking counsel from an actual one. And he found time for the least likely pupil in camp: Jay Hook, a pitcher, asked for help, and Hornsby taught him to drag bunt. Hook said he tied Robin Roberts that year as the best-hitting pitcher in the National League.



The Rajah vs. the Record Holder


That same spring, Hornsby published his autobiography, My War With Baseball — Stengel, of all people, wrote the foreword — and it picked a fight with the most famous slugger alive.



Hornsby had spent 1961 publicly backing Mickey Mantle over Roger Maris in the chase of Babe Ruth's home run record. "The only thing Maris could do better than the Babe," he said, "was run." Maris heard every word of it. On March 22, 1962, before an exhibition game in St. Petersburg, a UPI photographer named Joel Schrank talked Hornsby into a posed picture with Maris — the .358 hitter and the 61-homer champion, one from each era of the game. Hornsby grabbed a bat and walked to the Yankees' dugout. Maris refused. "Why should I?" he said. "He's done nothing but run me down. He says I can't hit."



Hornsby's reply went into every newspaper in America. "That bush leaguer," he said. "I've posed for pictures with some major league hitters, not bush leaguers like he is. He couldn't carry my bat." The Associated Press reported he also called Maris a "little punk." The same morning, Yankees first baseman Bill Skowron had sought Hornsby out and asked for help with his swing — fifteen minutes of it. "That's the difference," Hornsby said, "between a high-class fellow and a swelled-up guy."


The book landed three weeks later, with a chapter titled "There Won't Be Any More .400 Hitters," and it did not soften. Of Maris: "He couldn't hit .400 if he added all his averages together." Red Smith, the dean of the press box, sided with the old man. It was the last great baseball feud of Hornsby's life, and he fought it from the coaching box of a team that would lose 120 games.


Forty Wins


The 1962 Mets went 40–120, and no batting coach who ever lived was going to fix them. But look at what his two finished products did. Richie Ashburn, thirty-five years old and playing his final season, needed nothing from anybody — and hit .306 with a .424 on-base percentage, the club's only All-Star. Frank Thomas, the left fielder, hit 34 home runs — a franchise record that stood until Dave Kingman finally passed it in 1975.


Somebody asked Hornsby that year what he would hit if he were still playing, against the pitchers of 1962. He did the arithmetic honestly. "I guess I'd hit about .280 or .290," he said. And when the reporter wondered why the average was so low: "Well, I'm sixty-six years old. What do you expect?"


Gone Before the Second Spring


Hornsby did not return for 1963. He went home to Chicago, and in January he had surgery on the eyes he had protected for half a century — the eyes he had refused movies and books and newspapers to preserve. Days later, on January 5, 1963, Rogers Hornsby died of a heart attack. He was sixty-six years old, three months short of the Mets' second Opening Day. He is buried at Hornsby Bend, in the Texas ground his family gave its name to.


Stengel's foreword to his book turned out to be the epitaph, and it is the truest sentence anybody ever wrote about him: "He isn't a fellow who goes around shaking hands and saying nice things about people unless he means it. He said what he thought."


So print the whole line, the way this series always does — except this time the line is the argument. Twenty-three seasons. 2,259 games. 2,930 hits, 541 doubles, 169 triples, 301 home runs, 1,584 runs batted in. A .358 average, a .434 on-base percentage, a .577 slugging percentage. Seven batting titles. Two Triple Crowns. A .424 season that has outlived everyone who saw it.


And one final line that appears on no plaque: one season, 1962, New York Mets, batting coach, uniform No. 53.


Every hitting coach the Mets have employed since — and there have been beloved ones, and famous ones — has held a job that Rogers Hornsby held first. The most decorated man ever to sit in a Mets dugout never played an inning for the team. He just stood in its coaching box at the Polo Grounds for one summer, twenty years an immortal, teaching the worst hitters in baseball how the best one did it.


Forgotten? Only in Flushing.


Everywhere else, he's on the wall.


🔔 Get the Korner in Your Inbox


The Rumor Roundup, the Chronicles, Sunday School and everything from the Korner — delivered free every Sunday morning, plus a breaking-edition alert when the Mets make a move. Just drop your email in the form below and you're in.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page