top of page

Topps Tuesdays: 1967 Topps Mets — The Franchise Arrives on Cardboard

4 hours ago
9 min read


The games are over. The hot stove hasn't lit yet. This is the part of the year when a Mets fan's mind wanders — to the shoebox in the closet.


Last week we opened 1966, the year the Mets climbed out of last place and Tug McGraw got a card of his own. This week it's 1967 — and there's no easing into this one. Buried near the very end of the biggest set Topps had ever made, in the scarce high numbers, sits the most important rookie card in franchise history. Everything else in this week's binder is just the undercard.


Every Tuesday we open one year of Topps Mets cards, look at the full team set and what it carries today, and then you vote one card into the Mets Baseball Card Hall of Fame. Here's 1967.


The 1967 Topps Set


Topps broke the 600-card barrier for the first time in 1967: 609 cards, again across seven series, and a design so clean that collectors still call it one of the best of the decade. The familiar name-and-team box is gone. A big color photograph fills nearly the whole front, the player's name and position sit at the top, his facsimile autograph floats across the picture — back on Topps fronts for the first time in eight years — and the team name lands across the bottom in huge block letters. For the Mets, those letters are a loud, unmistakable pink-red. You can read "METS" off a 1967 card from across the room, and nothing else on the card competes with it.


Flip one over and Topps did something it had never done: the backs run vertical for the first time, in a lime green that shows every nick and corner touch — which is why nice '67s cost what they do. The subsets are the World Series Highlights (#151–155, back after a year away) and the League Leaders (#233–244), and the checklist cards get a makeover, carrying floating heads of the stars. The packs also held a new prize: All-Star Pin-Ups, 5"×7" posters folded down to pack size — Cleon Jones is the Mets' entry, poster #13.


The star power is enormous: Mickey Mantle at #150, Willie Mays at #200, Hank Aaron at #250, Roberto Clemente at #400, and Brooks Robinson closing the set at #600. The two rookie cards that anchor the whole issue are both high numbers — Rod Carew at #569 and, at #581, a Mets Rookies card we'll get to. The set's famous variations are none of them Mets: the rare Ed Spiezio (#128) missing letters from his name, Paul Schaal's green bat (#58), a handful of corrected checklists. The one Mets error is a typo on the back of Ron Swoboda's #264, where Rocky is described as "...a strong tnd extremely accurate..." thrower. And the set's strangest quirk: Milt Pappas (#254) is the only player in all 609 cards whose facsimile autograph was left off.


The Mets Checklist


The full team set runs 34 cards — 30 individual players and manager Wes Westrum, the team card, the Mets Maulers combo card, and two Rookie Stars cards (with a third rookie card, #587, counting through Mets pitcher Don Shaw).


The checklist:


#2 Jack Hamilton · #23 Larry Elliot · #42 Mets Team · #59 Ralph Terry · #91 Johnny Lewis · #105 Ken Boyer · #121 Ed Bressoud · #144 Bill Hepler · #165 Cleon Jones · #186 Mets Maulers (Kranepool/Swoboda) · #198 Chuck Hiller · #217 Rob Gardner · #264 Ron Swoboda · #287 Mets Rookies (Goossen/Shirley) · #306 Bud Harrelson · #348 Tug McGraw · #370 Tommy Davis · #386 Dick Selma · #413 Jerry Grote · #433 Al Luplow · #452 Ed Kranepool · #470 Bob Shaw · #487 Tommie Reynolds · #522 John Stephenson · #533 Jack Fisher · #537 Chuck Estrada · #555 Don Cardwell · #561 Sandy Alomar · #568 John Sullivan · #574 Jerry Buchek · #581 Mets Rookies (Denehy/Seaver) · #587 N.L. Rookies (Shaw/Sutherland) · #593 Wes Westrum · #606 Ron Taylor


Nine Mets live in the scarce seventh series — Estrada, Cardwell, Alomar, Sullivan, Buchek, the Seaver rookie, the Shaw rookie, Westrum and Taylor — and three more are double prints: Selma (#386), Luplow (#433) and Estrada (#537).


The ghost in this set wears a Washington uniform: Gil Hodges, #228, still managing the Senators. Within months of this set hitting the shelves he'd be the Mets' manager. Keep that in mind when we get to the bottom of the checklist, because Westrum's own card, #593, is a high number — and by the time the high numbers were in stores, Westrum had resigned (September 21, at 57–94) and Salty Parker was finishing out a 61–101, tenth-place season.


But nobody remembers 1967 for the standings. They remember it for the rookie. Tom Seaver won 16 games — more than a quarter of the team's total — with a 2.76 ERA, 18 complete games and 170 strikeouts, every one of those a franchise record. He made the All-Star team and saved the National League's win, and he was named the NL Rookie of the Year, the first Met ever to win a major postseason award. The rest of the rotation on cardboard tells you what he was carrying: Jack Fisher (#533) went 9–18, and the club used twenty different starting pitchers that summer — still a National League record. The lineup had one genuine bat — Tommy Davis (#370), the two-time batting champion acquired from the Dodgers, who hit .302 with 16 homers and 73 RBIs, leading the club in all three. And one future cornerstone is missing from this set entirely: Jerry Koosman debuted in 1967 too, but Topps didn't give him a card until 1968.



What It's Worth Today


The full 609-card set is a heavyweight: one national dealer currently lists a near-mint complete set at $37,016 (break-up value $56,290), because the high numbers — and one rookie in particular — punish anyone building it card by card.


And here, for once, the Mets are not the friendly end of the price list. The Seaver rookie is the most valuable card in the entire 1967 set. PSA counts just 3 copies in Gem Mint 10 — one sold for $344,400 — with 98 PSA 9s (most recent sale $16,870) and PSA 8s averaging around $3,900. Even raw, a decent Seaver rookie runs $800–$1,000. Centering is the card's usual condition problem: those narrow borders around the two rookie portraits leave almost no margin for error at the printing plant.


After Seaver, the team set settles back into common-card money, with the high numbers — Westrum, Taylor, Buchek, Alomar — carrying the usual scarcity premium, and the Maulers and Harrelson cards a step above common because two fan bases of memory are attached to them.


The Money Cards


#581 Mets Rookies — Bill Denehy / Tom Seaver — the key card of the entire 1967 set, full stop. Seaver's only recognized rookie card, a high number, and one of the defining cards of the decade.


#186 Mets Maulers — Kranepool / Swoboda — the beloved combo card; two of the most popular early Mets on one piece of cardboard.


#306 Bud Harrelson — Buddy's rookie card, and the shortstop of the Miracle Mets, arriving two years early.


#370 Tommy Davis — a two-time batting champion's only Topps card as a Met, and he played like it.


#593 Wes Westrum — a genuinely tough high number, and a poignant one: the manager on the card was gone before the season ended.


Five Cards to Sit With


#581 Mets Rookies — Bill Denehy / Tom Seaver. Turn the card sideways-to-history for a second and just look at it: two young right-handers in the yellow Rookie Stars frame, Denehy on the left, Seaver on the right, both of them grinning like the future is a rumor. Denehy's big-league career would be brief, and after the season he was sent to Washington as the compensation for the Mets hiring their manager away — Gil Hodges — which makes this card a two-for-one piece of franchise history: the Franchise himself, and the man whose departure delivered the manager who led him to 1969. Seaver's path here was its own lottery — literally: after the commissioner voided his Braves contract, the Mets won a drawing for his rights, and a year later he was the Rookie of the Year. There is no more important Mets baseball card. There is only the argument about whether anything else is even second.



#186 Mets Maulers — Ed Kranepool / Ron Swoboda. Topps looked at two kids who had combined for not much and labeled them MAULERS, in pink, at the bottom of the card. It was hope typeset as fact. Kranepool and Swoboda combined for 23 home runs in 1967, and they weren't even the team's top two power hitters — Tommy Davis hit 16 and Jerry Buchek 14. And then, on July 19, 1967, in the second game of a doubleheader against Houston at Shea, the Maulers homered in the same game — the only time all season — Kranepool in the sixth, Swoboda one out later, backing Tom Seaver's ninth win. A SABR game account exists just to commemorate the night this card told the truth. Both men also get solo cards in this set (#452, #264), but this is the one everybody kept.



#306 Bud Harrelson. Buddy's rookie card, and a quiet landmark: this is the first Topps card of the man who would play shortstop for both the 1969 and 1973 pennant winners, win a Gold Glove, coach, manage the club, and spend half a century as one of the most familiar faces in franchise history. The photo is pure Harrelson — crouched, glove down, all business, looking about 140 pounds of him. Rookie cards of franchise fixtures don't all have to be Seaver-priced to matter. This one is gettable, and it shouldn't be.



#370 Tommy Davis. The hired bat. Davis came from the Dodgers in the Ron Hunt trade with two batting titles and a broken ankle behind him, and for one season he was simply the best hitter the Mets had ever had: .302, 16 homers, 73 RBIs, the club leader across the board and only the second Mets regular ever to hit .300. His card is a big, smiling close-up — and a one-year Met's card that two fan bases collect, which is exactly the kind that holds its value.



#165 Cleon Jones. Look at the little gold trophy on the left of the card: Topps All-Star Rookie, earned in 1966, printed here like a credential. Jones was becoming the best everyday player the early Mets produced — he'd hit .297 in 1967 and .340 for the Miracle Mets — and the trophy makes this the most decorated-looking common card in the team set. He also represents the Mets in the Pin-Ups poster set tucked into the packs.


A few more worth a pause: Jerry Grote (#413) is in full crouch with the big mitt, already looking like the catcher who'd handle the '69 staff. Ken Boyer's #105 is his last card as a Met — he was traded to the White Sox in July, in the deal that brought Bill Robinson to New York. Tug McGraw (#348) gets his second solo card, a portrait this time. And Wes Westrum (#593) smiles out from the high numbers in his #51 jersey, weeks from resigning — the last Topps card of a manager whose replacement changed everything.


The Mets Baseball Card Hall of Fame


Three finalists this week. One vote. One plaque.


#581 Mets Rookies — Bill Denehy / Tom Seaver — Tom Seaver's rookie card. The Franchise, age 22, sharing a high-number Rookie Stars card at the end of the biggest set Topps ever made. The most important card in Mets history.


#186 Mets Maulers — Ed Kranepool / Ron Swoboda — The hope card. Topps called two kids "Maulers" before they'd earned it, and for one night at Shea in July 1967, they were. The most loved card in the set.


#306 Bud Harrelson — Buddy's rookie card. The 1969 shortstop arrives — crouched, ready, and four years from a Gold Glove — for common-card money and a lifetime of franchise history.


[★ WINNER SLOT — HALL OF FAME INDUCTION TO BE ADDED AFTER THE VOTE ★] The winning card's induction will be announced in this space once the vote is counted.


The vote is yours. Seaver, the Maulers, or Harrelson — cast it in the Topps Tuesdays group.


Full team set below — all 34 cards. Next Tuesday: 1968.




Join the conversation. The Topps Tuesdays group is where the weekly Hall of Fame poll lives — come vote, argue your pick, and show off your own '67s. And while you're there, poke around the rest of Talkin' Mets on the Korner: the Game Day Thread, Mets History & Memories, Hot Stove, Down on the Farm, and the Venting Booth for when the bullpen ruins your evening. Nine thousand Mets fans are waiting. Come talk baseball.


🔔 Get the Korner in Your Inbox


The Rumor Roundup, the Chronicles, Sunday School and everything from the Korner — delivered free every Sunday morning, plus a breaking-edition alert when the Mets make a move. Just drop your email in the form below and you're in.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page